When Should You Use a Travel Agent?

Southern Ocean meets Indian Ocean

My friend’s flight was delayed due to weather and this caused her and her family to miss their connection to London.  When she told me that she was flying from Philadelphia to New York to London, I gave her this obviously weird look and said “Why would the travel agent book that itinerary?” She replied, “we didn’t use a travel agent, we booked it online to save money”.  Well, her “savings” ended up costing her as the airline rebooked her the next day and they lost a day in London.  As they pre-paid for their apartment rental, they couldn’t get a credit for the day they lost.  All of this because it was easier to book online and not pay the travel agent $50 per ticket.

Tower Bridge London
Tower Bridge London on a fantastic day!

When I first started traveling (in those pre-internet days), you booked travel with a travel agent/agency.  You didn’t pay a fee because the airlines paid 10% commission and the other travel vendors also paid a commission.  Back in 1988, I remember driving to Liberty Travel in the mall to book my trip to Sydney and the Great Barrier Reef in Cairns.  The travel agent at that time booked the trip but couldn’t provide any insight for us as she had never been to Sydney, in fact, she hadn’t been out of the country.  She was only able to help us with the brochures she had and information provided by the company.

Sydney Harbour Bridge
Sydney Harbour Bridge

Fast forward to today in the age of the internet, mobile travel and travel blogs.  There is so much travel information out there that’s it’s often hard to dig deep to the level of detail that is helpful to you and at the same time it’s so easy to “do it on your own” that the travel agent is no longer the key point of contact for most travelers.  When was the last time you used a travel agent, if ever? At the New York Times Travel Show Industry Day, the experts all pointed to the rise of the custom itineraries, bespoke immersive experiences and the need for expert travel agents.

For me, I’ve found the value in (some) travel agents over the years (after my bad memories of the order taker in 1988) who have greatly enhanced the travel experience for me, saved me money and saved a trip.  While you may think you can do it all for travel, I offer up my reasons for using a travel agent:

1. It’s complicated!

This isn’t the title of my romantic life (although it could be many days), it refers to the fact that you have a complicated air itinerary that isn’t quite point A-B and back. It could be multi-city, multi-country or multi-airline/alliances.  A good travel agent can put a multi- airfare together and often save money over that internet fare you found.  Internet search engines aren’t quite that intuitive and often will price out your multi-city fare based on separate (more expensive) one way fares.  For example, if you want to fly to Los Angeles for a stopover then fly to San Francisco for a few days before coming home -it looks like PHL-LAX-SFO-PHL.  The internet will find the fare PHL-LAX, LAX-SFO and SFO-PHL whereas a travel agent can find fares that allow the LAX stopover.

Easter Island Moai
Moai of Easter Island

2. Which Cruise is Best for Me?

Finding the right cruise, the right ship and the perfect vacation is an art in my opinion.  A cruise expert will spend time (about 1/2 hour or more) interviewing you to get the information they need to match you to the perfect cruise.  I’m a big believer in cruise agents.  The cruise lines control their pricing so that all channels will shows the same price for the trip.  The difference (savings) in pricing generally comes in the form of on board credit (OBC), agency comps and specials.

Celebrity cruise Constellation
The Celebrity cruise from Istanbul to the Greek Isles and Turkey

An expert cruise agent has toured the ships, sailed the itineraries and knows which cabin is best for your specifics.  They will know about each restaurant onboard, the entertainment, the feel of the ship, the kids clubs, the ports, etc.  They love cruises and more likely than not, that’s the only type of vacation they take, they are all about the cruise, like my friend Mike.  Mike is always on a cruise (at least based on his Facebook updates) and after all of us telling him to become a cruise agent, he finally did and created CruiseStarter.

3. Destination Specific or WOW, the Country is Huge and I’m Clueless

When I traveled to New Zealand, I used a destination specialist travel agent located in Wellington, New Zealand.  She was a local who knew a lot more about traveling in her country than I could research and figure out.  I tried to find a U.S. based “expert” and did, but she wanted to stick me on a bus tour and charge the single supplement.  She didn’t plan out individual itineraries and didn’t have experience with solo travelers.  By working via email with the New Zealand agent, I had a magical ten-day trip that was beyond imagination and beyond what tour groups offered.

Lake Matheson mirror lake South Island New Zealand
Lake Matheson – worth the hike!

When I traveled on safari to Africa, Rhino Africa, located in Capetown, offered a plethora of option which worked perfectly.  Having met Nikki, the travel agent, at the New York Travel Show, I was able to email with her to nail down the specifics of my 27 Day Safari Itinerary.  She convinced me to stay at Oddballs in the Okavango Delta promising me an unforgettable experience – she was right!  She said stay at Inyati, I never heard of it, never read about it, was clueless and it was perfect!  When I tried to price out the trip direct on the internet with the vendors, the cost was so much more than Rhino offered – they deal direct with the vendors for special pricing.

Lion Big 5 animal on safari in South Africa Sabi Sands in Kruger
My first Lion sighting in Sabi Sands on Safari was quite memorable

4. My Boss Wants Me To Go There – The Corporate Travel Agent

I’ve managed corporate travel for nearly twenty years and in this space, the travel agent is invaluable to help with delays, cancellation, risk management, help with contracts/deals and changes along the way.  They are proactive for the traveler while staying within corporate policy as they understand both sides of the business traveler.

When the Icelandic volcano cloud interrupted international flights for days, our corporate agent made multiple booking for staff to be on the first flights out of the cities they were stranded in.  When a snow storm hit Paris years ago closing the Chunnel, my travel agent was able to rebook my flight to London earlier to avoid getting stuck in Paris. When we needed a preferred hotel, the agent set up a site visit at The Rosewood London.

Rosewood London entrance High Holborn
Rosewood London, our corporate hotel in London with a discount

5. I Just Want to Use My Points!

When my colleague wanted to find two tickets in January to Sydney and New Zealand and it was October, it was too much for me to do (I didn’t believe it could be done) so I referred him to the points travel booking services, Book Your Award.  They charge a fee, generally $150 and up per ticket but only when they find you the award ticket.  Despite me thinking this was a crazy request they were able to redeem AMEX points in his Delta account to redeem on the partner, Virgin Australia in business class.  Well worth the $300 fee for him and his wife. Saved him time and frankly, he has no clue that he could move the points like they did.  So pay the fee to save your sanity if you have miles and want a premium seat or complicated itinerary with stopovers, etc. Other options are Points Pros and Mile Value.

Sydney Opera House
Seeing Sydney twice is a dream realized with points

I still find value in using a travel agent in certain circumstances and, for me, having a long-standing relationship with a trusted agent is invaluable.  My personal travel agent has wait listed me on Amtrak for the lower fare (I didn’t even know this was an option!), rescued me from a bad hotel in Budapest by obtaining a refund on a non-refundable rate and has connections worldwide with concierges that have provided excellent information. My cruise agent sends updates when there are solo discounts, my Galapagos cruise agent is watching for a single cabin to open up this year and my corporate travel agent/agency helps me do my job in controlling costs while ensuring that my travelers are safe and traveling easy. I can’t do any of this by myself online which is why using a travel agent adds value.

Do you use a travel agent?  If not, when would you consider using one?

8 thoughts on “When Should You Use a Travel Agent?

  1. Good tips! Especially for choosing a cruise. You can go really wrong if you book a large cruise ship catering to younger partiers when you’d really prefer to listen to interesting lectures on a smaller ship. Even though we feel we’re pretty savvy when it comes to booking travel, we still use a travel agent for some arrangements – like when we visited Africa.

    1. Cruises are ripe for mismatch and where I feel a good agent that interviews you is best to find out likes/dislikes/etc. Despite my many years in corporate travel, I know when I’m over my head and need expert help – it really has made all the difference in the experiences I’ve had

  2. This is an excellent write-up. As you have precisely pointed out, I have always booked myself. We actually had great success in a tour of Malaysia in 2010 where our cost was way below any travel agent. However, we did have an issue with a hotel and had to figure it out on our own. I will find out agents now that I have read this. However, my concern remains reliability. How do I judge a travel agent? One way could be to try out recommendations. Please suggest, if feasible, ways and means to select and identify a trustworthy travel agent. Thanks

    1. Sourish – I am working on a follow up to this post to help find and weed out a good travel agent. As you note, recommendations are great and twitter and blogs are also good to crowdsource options. I’ve tested many people along the way before I found a few that I really like and trust. I did however go through a few agents that were to me “order takers” and not that interested in me but just selling x product. The good part of travel is that you can use an agent anywhere in the world – I’ve used agents outside of the U.S. to great success. Asking questions like “how many times have you personally visited x”, “what destinations are you an expert in and why?”, “what style of travel do you prefer planning”? If you want a bespoke trip and they book tour groups then not a good fit. Conde Nast Traveler has a section “Travel Agents” that they update each year with experts in all types of travel and destinations – its a good starting point and then interview the agents until you feel comfortable that they understand your needs now and in the future.

    1. Katrina – So happy to hear that you are using Rhino Africa, you are going to have an amazing safari experience! They really made it so easy to travel solo – every shuttle was on time per the itinerary – such a level of comfort to know you don’t need to worry about things – peace of mind is worth it. Have fun!

  3. We definitely used agents a few times in SE Asia – there are some activities/transport where that’s just usually how it’s done and it’s much easier, particularly in a totally foreign country.

    I think NZ can be easily self planned but glad you found a good agent!

Comments are closed.